@jiayifun
Back

We Are Small, and We Matter

💬 Deep Dive

The book “Why Fish Don’t Exist” was made popular by Meng Yan’s podcast “Nobody Knows”. This podcast has been listened to by more than 1 million people on Xiaoyuzhou.

This book also appeared in WeRead’s 2024 annual report. So in January of this year, I opened this book with some expectations. After reading two chapters, I felt that it was boring and too far away from my life.

But a book has been rated by more than 8,000 people on Douban, with a rating of 8.4. I can’t help but wonder what’s so good about it.

Last month, I opened “Why Fish Don’t Exist” again, and this time I read the third chapter.

After reading the third chapter, I was struck. In the third chapter, the author writes about her confusion and uneasiness in the process of growing up, as well as her doubts about the meaning of life, which made me very curious.

After reading it once, it was not enough, so I read it a second time.

I think this book should have a score of 8.8. It is obviously not an ordinary biography, but a book that asks about the meaning of life, or in other words, a book that looks for reasons to live.

On the one hand, it is like existentialism, ruthlessly exposing the meaningless nature of life, but in the end it gives people hope. Every person, every tree, every gust of wind is like a dandelion, seemingly insignificant, but very important, because nature has no hierarchical order, and the diversity brought about by mutation is the most wonderful.

1

The story begins with David Starr Jordan, the first president of Stanford University.

David was a taxonomist who spent his life classifying fish and named one-fifth of the world’s fish species. It’s a great feat, but you know, feats never come easy.

In 1883, while David was still teaching at Indiana University, one day in July of that year, a fire destroyed all the specimens David had collected and the secret documents he had painstakingly produced.

Then, within two years, his wife died of pneumonia.

One day in April 1906, a 7.9-magnitude earthquake struck San Francisco, once again destroying almost all of his fish specimens, taxonomic records, and research notes.

David was struck again and again but never destroyed. This is why the author is fascinated and curious about David: What is the power that allows David to survive fires, deaths of relatives, and earthquakes, continue his fish research, live tenaciously, and never be swallowed by despair?

The answer is “self-deception” or “positive illusion”.

David believed that man’s will determines his fate—the very lie he had said his entire life to oppose. But relying on this false belief, he continued to fight with willpower in the face of various sudden and unexpected blows.

Use action to fight against emptiness and futility, study fish all the time, and find a sense of order and control in taxonomy.

This kind of self-deception is called “positive illusion” in psychology. Psychological research has found that those who are mentally healthy often have “positive illusions” - they believe that they are smarter, more attractive, and more in control of outcomes than they actually are. But those who can clearly understand themselves and recognize reality often tend to suffer from depression.

Specifically, this optimistic misperception gives people the motivation to continue taking action when faced with setbacks or uncertainty—the ability to keep moving forward even after losing everything.

2

However, the positive illusion also has a dark side.

When a person deceives himself into thinking that “will can determine destiny,” then this overconfidence will inevitably turn into a kind of arrogance.

David embarked on this dangerous path of arrogance and became an enthusiastic supporter of eugenics. He arrogantly believed that humans could control nature through reason and will, and believed that nature had ladders. Human beings are at the pinnacle of nature, and within humans, there is also a hierarchical order, with some qualified and some unqualified.

In his eyes, the poor, the drunkards, the mentally retarded, the morally corrupt, etc., are unqualified and a burden to society and should be controlled through isolation or sterilization to prevent the deterioration of human quality.

He encouraged the government to implement large-scale sterilization operations, making California one of the first places in the United States to implement superior sterilization.

As a result, thousands of American women were forced to undergo hysterectomies in the name of eugenics.

Moreover, eugenics theory and the practices of the United States at that time were later regarded as important sources of the Nazi ideology of ethnic cleansing.

Moderate self-deception can help us persevere in difficult situations, but excessive self-deception can make us stubborn and lose objectivity, doubt, and awe of everything around us.

It is difficult for me to define what is “moderate” and what is “excessive”. The safest way is to continue to doubt and remain humble.

3

Ironically, when scientists later used DNA technology to re-examine David’s research, they discovered a shocking fact: the fish did not exist. Fish do not have a common ancestor, and this classification itself is wrong. Fish A may be more closely related to humans than fish B.

There seems to be some kind of fairness in the universe, but it may also be a coincidence, and David’s lifelong research does not exist.

Isn’t this another manifestation of human arrogance? We like to classify, label, and evaluate everything in terms of threes, sixes, nines, etc., as if this gives us a greater sense of control.

But the most wonderful thing about nature is that the diversity brought about by mutation has no fixed advantages or disadvantages, it only depends on the adaptability to the environment, and the environment itself is ever-changing.

As the author puts it, the dandelion principle: the same dandelion is a weed to a gardener, a medicine to a pharmacist, and a wish-making tool to children. Its value is not fixed but depends on the person who develops a relationship with it.

From the perspective of the grand universe or eugenics, a person’s life is extremely small and insignificant; but for a family and a network of relationships, a seemingly ordinary person is the most important existence.

Put aside the imaginary hierarchy and classification concepts, and find your own value and meaning in real relationships.

Final

Humans are no smarter than other creatures.

Human beings, specifically every individual, are just like other creatures, both small and important, insignificant and irreplaceable.

🧵 One More Thing

This newsletter has canceled the Curated Gems section and I moved it to my daily blog.

You can read it by following my official account, Xiaohongshu, or Quaily and RSS.

There are three types of content I’m creating:

I’m not good at self-promotion. If you like my content, please help me share it more😄

I am also hesitating, do I need to continue writing a newsletter? Are you too greedy and want to do everything? Writing a newsletter is of course mental gymnastics and self-training, but compared to videos and blogs, does it put a lot more pressure on readers? I’m still hesitating.

One reason that makes me hesitate is that this issue happens to be the 50th issue, which is a suitable node for making decisions😄

If I stop writing, I will also send a notice to everyone, but I think even if I don’t write, it is just a pause button, not a termination button.